Spiral State Psychiatry
A Real-Time, Non-Diagnostic Framework for Mental Health and Flourishing
Spiral State Psychiatry offers a transformative approach to mental healthcare, moving beyond the limitations of traditional diagnostic models. This framework embraces the inherent fluidity and dynamism of human experience, understanding mental health not as a fixed state, but as a continuous, evolving journey through various "lived states."
We focus on real-time observation and analysis of individual patterns, rhythms, and fluctuations, providing a nuanced understanding that empowers individuals to navigate their unique pathways towards well-being and flourishing. By emphasising co-creation and personalised support, this non-diagnostic paradigm fosters resilience, growth, and a deeper attunement to one's inner and relational dynamics.
The Failure of the Diagnostic Model
History and critique of DSM/ICD
The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) and International Classification of Diseases (ICD) have long served as the cornerstone of psychiatric diagnosis. These systems were developed with the intention of bringing standardisation and reliability to the classification of mental health conditions, aiming to facilitate research, clinical communication, and treatment planning.
However, over decades of use, these systems have increasingly come under scrutiny for their reductionist approach to human suffering and experience. Critics argue that by relying predominantly on symptom checklists and categorical classifications, the DSM and ICD often oversimplify complex human phenomena, treating them as distinct, fixed entities rather than fluid, context-dependent states. This approach frequently leads to the reification of disorders, where diagnostic labels can be perceived as concrete diseases rather than descriptive summaries of symptom clusters.
Furthermore, a significant point of contention is the absence of clear biological markers 🧬 for most psychiatric diagnoses. Unlike many medical conditions, mental health diagnoses largely remain based on observable symptoms and subjective reports, raising questions about their scientific validity and the potential for over-medicalisation. This categorical model also struggles to capture the dimensional nature of human experience, where symptoms often exist on a spectrum rather than as discrete presence or absence.
The impact extends beyond theoretical debates, affecting individuals directly through the stigma associated with labels, and potentially limiting a holistic understanding of their unique struggles, personal strengths, and socio-environmental contexts. The limitations highlight an urgent need for models that can account for the dynamic, nuanced, and individual nature of mental well-being, moving beyond a sole reliance on static diagnostic categories. ⚖️
Perspectives on Psychiatric Diagnosis
Perspectives from service-user movements, anti-psychiatry, and anthropological studies have profoundly shaped the ongoing critical discourse surrounding traditional psychiatric diagnosis. These diverse viewpoints collectively challenge the assumed universality and scientific objectivity of diagnostic labels, advocating for more nuanced and context-aware understandings of mental distress and well-being.
Service-User Movements
Those with lived experience of mental health systems have increasingly organised to challenge diagnostic frameworks that often fail to capture their complex realities. These movements emphasise the importance of first-person accounts and experiential knowledge in understanding mental distress, advocating for a shift from a purely medical model to one that prioritises recovery-oriented care, peer support, and self-determination. They highlight how diagnoses can sometimes be limiting, leading to stigma and overlooking an individual's unique strengths and pathways to healing.
Anti-Psychiatry Critique
Scholars and practitioners within the anti-psychiatry movement have questioned the fundamental assumptions of psychiatric diagnosis, arguing that these systems often pathologise normal human responses to difficult circumstances and social injustice. Critics contend that diagnostic labels can serve to medicalise social problems, divert attention from root causes like poverty or trauma, and strip individuals of their agency. They suggest that the concept of "mental illness" itself is largely a social construct, used to control and conform those who deviate from societal norms.
Anthropological Insights
Cross-cultural studies reveal how mental distress is understood and addressed differently across societies, highlighting the culturally constructed nature of psychiatric categories that are often presented as universal truths. What might be deemed a disorder in one culture could be seen as a spiritual experience or a temporary state in another. These insights underscore the limitations of applying Western-centric diagnostic manuals globally without considering local contexts, belief systems, and healing practices, challenging the notion of a single, universal pathology.
Collectively, these perspectives call for a paradigm shift, moving beyond a narrow diagnostic lens to embrace more holistic, person-centred, and socially informed approaches to understanding and supporting mental health.
The Trauma of Pathologisation
For many individuals, receiving a psychiatric diagnosis can itself become a profoundly traumatic experience. Far from being neutral descriptions, these static labels often fail to capture the dynamic, contextual, and deeply personal nature of human experience. Instead, they can inadvertently lead to significant distress, fostering stigmatisation, eroding self-efficacy, and severely narrowing an individual's perceived potential for growth, healing, and meaningful change. This process can transform a complex lived reality into a fixed, often deficit-focused, identity.
Identity Reduction
Diagnostic labels can profoundly overshadow the full complexity of a person's identity. Instead of recognising a whole human being with unique strengths, capabilities, and a rich personal history, individuals are often reduced to a collection of symptoms. This reduction can lead to self-stigma, impact social interactions, and limit the scope of interventions to merely managing symptoms rather than fostering holistic well-being and personal flourishing. The label can become a dominant narrative, eclipsing other facets of one's selfhood.
Temporal Limitations
Static diagnoses inherently fail to account for the fluctuating, evolving nature of mental states across time, different life stages, and varying contexts. Human experience is not fixed; it is inherently fluid, responsive, and dynamic. Imposing a fixed diagnostic category can create artificial boundaries around experiences that are constantly shifting, potentially overlooking periods of resilience, growth, and spontaneous recovery. This static view can impede the recognition of an individual's capacity for change and obscure the contextual factors that influence their well-being.
Power Imbalance
The diagnostic process often reinforces hierarchical power dynamics between clinicians and those seeking help. In this model, the clinician holds the authority to name and define an individual's experience, which can inadvertently undermine the agency, self-knowledge, and intrinsic wisdom of the individual in their own healing journey. This imbalance can lead to a medicalised gaze overriding lived experience, potentially fostering dependence rather than empowering individuals to actively participate in understanding and navigating their distress.
Stigmatisation and Exclusion
Receiving a psychiatric diagnosis frequently carries a heavy burden of societal stigma, leading to discrimination in various aspects of life, including employment, housing, and social relationships. The labels can foster an "us vs. them" mentality, contributing to social exclusion and isolation. This external judgment can be internalised, perpetuating feelings of shame and self-blame, thereby becoming a significant barrier to seeking help or engaging in community, further entrenching the traumatic impact of pathologisation.
Living Alternatives
Open Dialogue, process-based therapy, dimensional models
In response to the limitations of traditional diagnostic approaches, several alternative frameworks have emerged that emphasise process, dialogue, and dimensional understanding rather than categorical diagnosis.
These innovative models offer more nuanced and holistic perspectives on mental well-being, focusing on an individual's unique experiences and pathways to healing, rather than simply categorising symptoms.
💬 Open Dialogue Approach
Originating in Finland, the Open Dialogue approach emphasises immediate, network-based treatment meetings that include the individual, their family, and social network, alongside the care team. This method prioritises open communication, shared understanding, and collaborative decision-making, aiming to create new solutions without relying on pre-existing diagnoses. It fosters a sense of agency and collective responsibility in the healing process.
🔄 Process-Based Therapy (PBT)
Process-Based Therapy shifts the focus from static diagnostic labels to the dynamic, underlying psychological processes that contribute to an individual's distress. Instead of treating symptoms in isolation, PBT examines transdiagnostic processes such as emotional regulation, cognitive flexibility, and interpersonal patterns. This approach allows for highly individualised interventions, tailored to the specific mechanisms driving a person's challenges, and can adapt as these processes evolve over time.
📊 Dimensional Models
Dimensional models move away from the categorical "either/or" thinking of traditional diagnoses. Instead, they propose that mental health experiences exist along a spectrum, allowing for a more nuanced understanding of severity, comorbidity, and individual variation. This perspective acknowledges that many aspects of human experience, including emotional distress, are best understood as varying in degree rather than as distinct illnesses. Dimensional approaches can facilitate more precise assessment and more personalised treatment planning.
Open Dialogue Approach
Developed in Finland, the Open Dialogue approach represents a radical departure from conventional psychiatric treatment. It is a comprehensive network-based intervention for psychiatric crises, emphasising the involvement of the client's social network in all meetings and fostering a continuous, dialogical process. This methodology aims to prevent chronicity and reduce the need for medication by focusing on immediate, collaborative, and flexible responses to distress.
Key operational principles that guide the Open Dialogue approach include:
- ⏰ Immediate intervention during crisis: Rather than waiting, professional help is offered within 24 hours of contact. This rapid response helps to de-escalate crisis situations and prevent the consolidation of symptoms, creating an opportunity for early, effective support.
- 🤝 Social network involvement in all meetings: The client's family, friends, and other significant people in their lives are invited to participate in all discussions. This collaborative approach ensures a shared understanding of the situation and collective responsibility for finding solutions.
- 🌍 Flexibility and mobility in response: Meetings are held wherever is most comfortable and convenient for the client and their network, often in their homes. The frequency and duration of meetings are adapted to the unique needs of the situation, allowing for a highly personalised and responsive care model.
- ✅ Responsibility of the first contacted professional: The professional who first makes contact with the client typically remains the primary therapist throughout the entire process, fostering a sense of continuity and trust. This ensures a consistent therapeutic relationship, avoiding the fragmentation often seen in traditional care models.
- 🔗 Psychological continuity throughout the process: The same team of professionals, often two, works with the client and their network consistently from the initial contact through the entire course of treatment. This promotes a stable and predictable environment for dialogue and healing.
The core philosophical principles underpinning Open Dialogue are essential to its effectiveness:
- 🤔 Tolerance of uncertainty: Professionals are encouraged to avoid premature diagnoses and assumptions, instead embracing the ambiguity of the situation. This allows for a more open and genuine exploration of the client's experiences without imposing pre-conceived notions.
- 🗣️ Dialogism and polyphony in network meetings: All voices in the network are actively encouraged to speak and be heard. The goal is to create a multi-voiced dialogue where different perspectives are welcomed and no single "truth" is privileged, allowing new meanings to emerge collectively.
- 🎯 Responding to the specific needs of each unique situation: Treatment is not standardised but is instead tailored precisely to the individual and their social context. This bespoke approach recognises the inherent uniqueness of each person's experience of distress.
- 🌱 Focusing on generating dialogue rather than promoting change: The primary aim is to facilitate open and honest conversations within the network, believing that meaningful change will naturally emerge from this dialogical process. The emphasis is on understanding and connection, not on directly fixing problems.
- ⏳ Emphasising the present moment in therapeutic conversations: Discussions are grounded in the immediate experiences and interactions of the network during the meeting. This "here and now" focus helps to reveal dynamic patterns and foster spontaneous, authentic communication, moving beyond past narratives or future anxieties.
By integrating these operational and philosophical principles, Open Dialogue offers a powerful humanistic alternative to traditional psychiatric care, fostering recovery and resilience within individuals and their social systems.
Process-Based Therapy
Process-based therapy (PBT) represents a significant evolution in psychological intervention, moving beyond the traditional limitations of manualised treatment protocols that often prioritise symptom reduction. Instead, PBT focuses on the underlying mechanisms and dynamic processes of change that contribute to psychological distress and well-being. This innovative approach recognises that truly effective and lasting intervention requires a deep and nuanced attention to:
1
Core Processes
Identifying and targeting the fundamental psychological processes that underlie various forms of distress, rather than solely focusing on symptom clusters or diagnostic labels. This includes exploring mechanisms such as experiential avoidance, cognitive fusion, values incongruence, or deficits in self-regulation, which are often transdiagnostic and critical to lasting change.
2
Psychological Flexibility
Developing the capacity to adapt responses to changing circumstances and internal states, rather than rigidly adhering to predetermined or maladaptive patterns. This involves fostering skills in mindfulness, acceptance, cognitive defusion, self-as-context, and committed action, enabling individuals to respond more effectively to life's challenges and align their behaviour with deeply held values.
3
Contextual Sensitivity
Recognising and actively addressing how environmental, social, and cultural factors profoundly shape psychological experiences and responses to intervention. PBT emphasises understanding the individual within their broader life context, including socio-economic conditions, cultural norms, and relational dynamics, ensuring that interventions are relevant and respectful of their unique lived reality.
4
Personalised Approach
Tailoring therapeutic strategies to the unique needs, values, and circumstances of each individual rather than applying one-size-fits-all protocols. This involves a continuous, data-driven assessment of what processes are active for a client at any given time and how best to intervene to shift these processes, making therapy highly individualised and responsive.
By shifting the focus from diagnostic categories to the dynamic interplay of these core processes within an individual's unique context, Process-Based Therapy offers a more dynamic, empirical, and individualised approach to mental health care. This methodology aims to cultivate sustainable change, empowering individuals to navigate their internal and external worlds with greater adaptive capacity and resilience, moving beyond symptom management to genuine flourishing.
Dimensional Models
Dimensional models of mental health offer a powerful alternative to traditional categorical diagnoses, moving beyond binary classifications of "disordered" versus "normal." Instead, they recognise the inherent continuity and spectrum nature of psychological experiences, providing a more comprehensive and nuanced understanding of human well-being. These approaches enable us to:
Embrace Continuous Dimensions
Rather than placing individuals into rigid, discrete categories, dimensional models measure psychological experiences along multiple continuous scales. This allows for a more precise depiction of an individual's unique profile across various traits and states, such as mood, anxiety, thought patterns, and social functioning, without forcing them into predefined boxes.
Capture Nuance and Variability
By acknowledging the spectrum nature of psychological traits and states, these models can better capture the immense complexity and variability inherent in human experience. They highlight that psychological characteristics exist on a continuum, allowing for a more subtle and individualised understanding of differences between people, rather than oversimplifying them into presence or absence of a disorder.
Reduce Artificial Boundaries and Stigma
A key benefit of dimensional models is their capacity to significantly reduce the artificial boundaries between "clinical" and "non-clinical" populations. This approach fosters a perspective where distress is seen as a deviation along a spectrum rather than an all-or-nothing condition, which can help to de-pathologise common human struggles and reduce the stigma often associated with mental health labels. It encourages a focus on support and intervention tailored to an individual's specific needs along these dimensions.
By shifting from a categorical to a dimensional framework, mental health professionals can develop more personalised and effective interventions that address the specific intensity and configuration of an individual's experiences, fostering a more holistic and compassionate approach to care. This also facilitates research into the underlying mechanisms of psychological phenomena, leading to more targeted and preventative strategies.
Neurodivergence and the Plural Mind
Neurodiversity Paradigm
The neurodiversity movement reframes conditions like autism, ADHD, and dyslexia not as disorders to be cured but as natural, valuable variations in human cognition. This paradigm shifts the focus from deficits to differences, promoting a more inclusive understanding of the human brain. This perspective:
- 🎉 Celebrates cognitive differences as valuable to human diversity, enriching society with varied perspectives and talents.
- 🛡️ Challenges deficit-focused medical models that historically pathologised neurodevelopmental conditions, instead advocating for a strengths-based approach.
- 🤝 Advocates for environmental and societal accommodations rather than demanding neurodivergent individuals conform to neurotypical norms, fostering environments where all brain types can thrive.
- 🗣️ Emphasises the importance of self-advocacy and community building among neurodivergent individuals, fostering a sense of identity and belonging.
- 🌍 Promotes a broader understanding that neurological diversity is a fundamental aspect of human biodiversity, similar to biodiversity in ecosystems.
Plurality and Multiplicity
Emerging understandings of plurality recognise that the human mind is not necessarily singular or monolithic but may naturally contain multiple self-states, parts, or identities. This framework moves beyond traditional, often pathologising, interpretations of multiplicity to acknowledge it as a spectrum of human experience. This framework:
- 🌈 Acknowledges the broad spectrum of plural experiences, from everyday shifts in self-perception to more distinct "parts" or internal systems.
- 🌱 Moves beyond pathologising approaches to multiplicity, viewing it not as a flaw or disorder (unless causing significant distress or dysfunction), but as a complex and sometimes adaptive way the mind organises itself.
- 💪 Recognises the adaptive functions of diverse self-states, which can include specialised coping mechanisms, creative outlets, and unique ways of processing information and interacting with the world.
- ❤️ Encourages curiosity and compassion towards internal multiplicity, fostering internal communication and cooperation rather than suppression or eradication.
- 🧠 Highlights that many common therapeutic approaches, such as Internal Family Systems (IFS) or ego-state therapy, implicitly work with the concept of a plural mind, even if not explicitly using the term "neurodivergence."
Both the neurodiversity paradigm and the concept of a plural mind challenge conventional notions of psychological "normality," paving the way for more affirming, person-centred, and nuanced approaches to mental health and well-being. They encourage a shift from asking "What's wrong with you?" to "What happened to you?" and "How does your mind uniquely work?"
Emergent Models
Beyond traditional diagnostic frameworks, a new wave of emergent ecological, narrative, and relational models offers a more holistic understanding of mental well-being. These perspectives challenge reductionist views, focusing instead on the dynamic interplay of individual experience with broader systems and contexts.
1
🌍 Ecological
This model views mental health within nested environmental contexts, recognising that an individual's well-being is deeply interconnected with their family systems, community networks, cultural backgrounds, and broader societal structures. It emphasises how factors like social support, economic conditions, and access to resources significantly influence psychological states, moving beyond an exclusive focus on internal pathology.
2
📖 Narrative
The narrative approach centres personal meaning-making and storied experience as fundamental to mental health. It posits that individuals construct their identities and understanding of the world through the stories they tell about themselves and their lives. Therapeutic work often involves exploring, deconstructing, and co-creating new narratives that empower individuals and foster resilience, rather than simply identifying symptoms.
3
🤝 Relational
Focusing on patterns of connection and interaction, the relational model highlights the crucial role of interpersonal relationships in shaping mental health. It examines how early attachments, current social bonds, and communication styles contribute to emotional regulation, self-esteem, and overall psychological functioning. Distress is often understood as arising from relational disconnections or unhealthy interaction patterns, and healing is found through fostering secure and supportive relationships.
These emerging frameworks share a profound commitment to understanding mental health not as an isolated individual internal state but as arising from complex interactions between persons, their communities, and diverse environments. They consistently emphasise context, personal meaning, and authentic connection as core elements for well-being, moving decisively beyond isolated symptoms or biological reductionism. This shift opens new pathways for integrated and compassionate approaches to care.
Spiral State Theory
Recursive attention, field-based cognition, polyvagal theory
Spiral State Theory offers a dynamic framework for understanding mental health that integrates insights from neuroscience, systems theory, and contemplative traditions. At its core is the recognition that consciousness operates through recursive patterns that spiral through time rather than linear progressions.
This framework posits that mental states are not static points but rather dynamic, self-organising processes. Recursive attention, for instance, highlights how our focus continuously loops back on itself, shaping and being shaped by our perceptions, memories, and expectations. This constant self-referential loop can either lead to adaptive, coherent states or maladaptive, stuck patterns.
Furthermore, Spiral State Theory incorporates the concept of field-based cognition, which views consciousness and mental processes not as isolated within the brain but as emergent properties of an individual's continuous interaction with their environment and social context. This emphasises the profound influence of relational and ecological fields on our inner experience. Finally, Polyvagal Theory provides a crucial physiological lens, explaining how the autonomic nervous system constantly modulates our states of engagement, fight/flight, or shutdown, influencing our capacity for connection and resilience. Together, these elements paint a comprehensive picture of the spiralling, interconnected nature of human experience and well-being.
Recursive Attention
Recursive Attention is a cornerstone of Spiral State Theory, offering a profound reinterpretation of how consciousness engages with itself and its environment. It moves beyond linear models of focus, revealing attention as a dynamic, self-referential process that shapes and is shaped by our lived experience.
Self-Referential Awareness 🔄
Recursive attention fundamentally describes the mind's unique capacity to turn its focus inward, observing its own operations. This isn't merely passive introspection but a dynamic process where awareness creates feedback loops upon itself, leading to the generation of increasingly nuanced and complex states of mind. This profound capacity for meta-awareness empowers individuals to not only identify but also intricately analyse the underlying patterns within their own thought, emotion, and sensory processes, distinguishing between fleeting impulses and deeper, recurring mental landscapes. Understanding this self-observational loop is key to cultivating greater mental agility and self-regulation.
Attentional Spirals 🌀
Moving beyond the simplistic 'spotlight' metaphor often used to describe attention, Spiral State Theory posits that attention operates through intricate, recursive patterns—'attentional spirals.' These spirals are not static but dynamic, capable of either amplifying existing mental states, driving them into deeper or more intense configurations (e.g., anxiety spiralling into panic), or profoundly transforming them into new forms of awareness. This happens through continuous feedback loops where the act of attending to something subtly alters that thing, which in turn influences subsequent acts of attention. Recognising these spirals allows for deliberate shifts in focus that can break negative loops and foster more adaptive mental states.
Nested Awareness 🕸️
Each moment of attention, rather than being a discrete, isolated point, contains within it inherent traces and echoes of previous moments. This creates a deeply interconnected, 'nested' structure of experience that spirals through time rather rather than proceeding in a strictly linear, step-by-step fashion. This means our present perception is always imbued with the resonances of our past, influencing how we interpret and respond to current stimuli. This continuous layering of experience enables a rich, textured understanding of reality and underpins the development of complex cognitive structures and emotional landscapes, highlighting the deep interdependence of temporal experiences within consciousness.
Field-Based Cognition
Moving beyond localised models of brain function that primarily focus on specific brain regions, field-based cognition recognises that mental processes and consciousness itself emerge from distributed networks of activity across the entire nervous system, encompassing the brain, body, and even environmental interactions. This perspective challenges traditional views by highlighting the interconnected and dynamic nature of cognitive phenomena, suggesting that our experience is not confined to a single organ but is a holistic process.
Beyond Brain-Centrism
Field-based approaches fundamentally recognise that cognition extends far beyond the confines of the brain. It actively includes the entire physiological system, acknowledging the crucial role of the body in shaping our thoughts, emotions, and perceptions. Furthermore, it emphasises that our mental life is deeply intertwined with continuous interactions with both the social and physical environment, suggesting a constant feedback loop between internal states and external contexts.
Resonant Fields
From this perspective, mental states are not static entities but are understood as dynamic, resonant fields of activity. These fields possess a remarkable capacity to entrain with external rhythms and patterns, including the subtle and often unconscious signals generated by other people's nervous systems. This concept helps explain phenomena like empathy, group cohesion, and shared emotional experiences, where individuals' internal states can synchronise and influence one another.
Emergent Properties
The field-based model highlights that complex cognitive and emotional states are not merely the sum of their parts, but rather emergent properties that arise from the intricate interaction of simpler processes. This means that consciousness, self-awareness, and nuanced emotional experiences manifest from the collective activity of these distributed networks, creating phenomena that cannot be fully reduced or understood by analysing only their individual components in isolation.
Polyvagal Theory
Developed by Stephen Porges, Polyvagal Theory provides a neurophysiological framework for understanding how the autonomic nervous system mediates social engagement, threat response, and recovery. It emphasises the hierarchical organisation of the vagal nerve branches and their distinct roles in influencing our physiological and emotional states, profoundly impacting our capacity for connection, safety, and resilience.
1
1
Ventral Vagal
The newest branch of the vagus nerve, associated with social engagement and feelings of safety. This state facilitates connection, co-regulation, and allows for calm, accessible social interaction. When in this state, individuals can think clearly, engage empathetically, and experience a sense of peace and security.
Physiologically, the ventral vagal state is characterised by regulated heart rate, improved digestion, and activation of facial muscles for expression and listening, supporting a "rest and digest" mode within a context of social connection.
2
2
Sympathetic
This system mobilises the body for action, preparing it for "fight or flight" responses when a threat is perceived. It's characterised by increased heart rate, rapid breathing, muscle tension, and heightened alertness. While essential for survival, chronic sympathetic activation can lead to anxiety, restlessness, and hypervigilance.
This state is crucial for active defence and engagement, allowing individuals to respond swiftly to challenges. However, prolonged activation without resolution can deplete resources and lead to chronic stress-related health issues.
3
3
Dorsal Vagal
The oldest branch of the vagus nerve, responsible for an immobilisation or "freeze" response when faced with overwhelming threat. This state is often characterised by dissociation, collapse, and feelings of hopelessness or profound shutdown. It's an ancient protective mechanism, reducing pain and conserving energy when escape or fight is not possible.
In this state, metabolic activity slows down significantly, potentially leading to fainting, numbness, or a sense of being "checked out." While adaptive in extreme circumstances, prolonged dorsal vagal activation can manifest as depression, chronic fatigue, and a sense of detachment from one's body and environment.
Spiral State Theory integrates Polyvagal insights to understand how these autonomic states form recursive patterns that can either maintain distress or facilitate healing through rhythmic shifts between activation and recovery. It highlights that mental well-being is not a static condition but a dynamic process of navigating these states, recognising that prolonged "stuckness" in any one state can be detrimental. The theory emphasises the importance of understanding these shifts as part of a continuous, spiralling process, rather than linear progression, offering new avenues for therapeutic intervention focused on enhancing flexibility and resilience within the nervous system.
Critique of Polyvagal Theory
While highly influential in various fields, from psychology to trauma-informed care, Stephen Porges' Polyvagal Theory has also drawn significant academic scrutiny and debate. Like any foundational framework, its broad application warrants a closer look at its foundational claims and limitations.
Anatomical Specificity
Critics question the precise anatomical and physiological evidence for the strict hierarchical separation and distinct functional roles of the vagal branches, particularly the "ventral vagal complex," as conceptualised for humans. Research suggests a more integrated, less distinctly hierarchical autonomic system.
Oversimplification
Some argue the theory oversimplifies the highly complex and networked interactions within the autonomic nervous system. Autonomic regulation involves a broader range of brain structures and neurotransmitters than primarily the vagus nerve, and not all responses neatly fit into the proposed three states.
Empirical Validation
While the theory offers compelling narratives, some therapeutic applications and interpretations derived from it lack robust, direct empirical validation through rigorous scientific studies. More research is needed to substantiate claims regarding specific interventions and their mechanisms of action.
Despite these critiques, Polyvagal Theory remains a valuable conceptual lens for understanding physiological responses to threat and safety, and its emphasis on the body's role in emotional regulation has significantly advanced trauma-informed approaches. The ongoing scientific discourse is essential for refining and strengthening our understanding of the nervous system.
Temporal Coherence
Temporal coherence, fluctuation patterns, nested rhythms
A central aspect of Spiral State Theory is its focus on how mental states unfold dynamically across multiple timescales, from rapid moment-to-moment fluctuations in thought and emotion to longer developmental arcs of personal growth and systemic patterns. Temporal coherence, in this context, refers to the meaningful and integrated organisaton of experience across these diverse rhythms. It highlights how a sense of stability and well-being emerges when these internal and external rhythms are aligned and flow harmoniously, rather than being fragmented or chaotic.
Fluctuation Patterns
describe the dynamic, continuous ebb and flow of mental and emotional states. Rather than seeing states as static or fixed, we recognise their inherent variability and the unique signatures of their shifts. Understanding these patterns—their amplitude, frequency, and predictability—provides crucial insights into an individual's current state and their capacity for adaptation.
Nested Rhythms
refers to the concept that these fluctuations do not occur in isolation but are embedded within larger, overarching cycles. Just as biological rhythms like heartbeats and breath cycles are nested within daily circadian rhythms, and these within seasonal or developmental rhythms, mental states are influenced by layered patterns. Recognising these nested rhythms allows for a deeper appreciation of the complex interplay between immediate experience and broader life contexts.
By integrating these concepts, Spiral State Theory offers a nuanced understanding of mental health that moves beyond static diagnostic labels. Instead, it emphasises the dynamic, rhythmic nature of lived experience, providing a foundation for interventions that support the restoration of natural coherence and adaptive fluctuation rather than simply suppressing symptoms.
Fluctuation Patterns
Mental states are inherently dynamic, not static, and are characterised by continuous, often predictable, patterns of fluctuation. Spiral State Theory offers a framework to meticulously map and interpret these subtle yet significant fluctuations, moving beyond simplistic notions of fixed states or discrete disorders. By understanding these inherent rhythms, we can gain deeper insights into the complex adaptive dance of the mind.
This mapping allows for a nuanced understanding of:
- 〰️ Natural oscillations between different states of arousal and rest: Recognising the inherent ebb and flow of energy, from periods of high alertness to deep relaxation, as part of a healthy system.
- 🔄 Patterns of reactivity and recovery in response to stressors: Identifying typical responses to challenges and the natural processes through which individuals return to a baseline or adapt to new equilibrium.
- 🌊 Cycles of expansion and contraction in emotional experience: Understanding that emotions, even challenging ones, move in waves, allowing for the natural processing and integration of feelings rather than their suppression.
- 🧭 Rhythmic shifts between different modes of attention and awareness: Observing how focus naturally broadens and narrows, or shifts between internal and external worlds, influencing perception and engagement.
By recognising these intrinsic patterns, individuals can develop greater awareness of their own state fluctuations and learn to work with rather than against these natural rhythms. This approach differs fundamentally from traditional models that aim to eliminate perceived "abnormal" fluctuations in favour of achieving stable, often rigid, "normal" states. Instead, Spiral State Theory embraces the inherent dynamism of human experience, seeing these fluctuations not as symptoms to be eradicated, but as vital information about a person's unique adaptive landscape.
Embracing fluctuation patterns means fostering resilience by understanding and navigating the natural variations of the mind. It allows for the development of personalised strategies that align with an individual's unique biological and psychological rhythms, leading to more sustainable well-being. This perspective encourages self-compassion and reduces the internal pressure to conform to an idealised, static notion of mental health, promoting a more fluid and adaptive relationship with one's inner experience.
Nested Rhythms
Building upon the concept of fluctuating mental states, Spiral State Theory posits that these fluctuations are not random but organised into nested rhythms, operating simultaneously across various temporal scales. Understanding these inherent, multi-layered patterns is crucial for comprehending the dynamic nature of human experience and well-being, moving beyond a singular, static view of mental health. These rhythms provide a framework for observing how our internal states are continuously shaped by internal and external influences.
1
Momentary Fluctuations
Second-to-second shifts in attention, arousal, and immediate physiological responses.
2
Diurnal Patterns
Daily cycles of energy, mood, cognitive function, and sleep-wake patterns, influenced by circadian rhythms.
3
Seasonal Rhythms
Longer cycles tied to environmental, social, and cultural patterns, impacting mood, energy, and behaviour over months.
4
Developmental Arcs
Life-span patterns of growth, integration, transformation, and evolving capacities, reflecting broader phases of human development.
Spiral State Theory recognises how these different temporal scales interact, with patterns at one level influencing and being influenced by patterns at other levels. For instance, a challenging momentary fluctuation might ripple through and affect a daily pattern, or a developmental arc might predispose an individual to certain seasonal shifts. This interconnectedness highlights the complexity and adaptability of the human system.
Mental health interventions can effectively target different temporal scales depending on the nature of the challenge and available resources. By aligning interventions with these natural rhythms, care becomes more attuned to the individual's inherent dynamic processes, fostering resilience and promoting a more fluid, adaptive relationship with their mental states rather than enforcing rigid stability.
Real-Time Ethnography and Somatic Tech
Mapping Lived States
Mapping lived states with biosensors, voice, and body metrics offers a revolutionary approach in Spiral State Psychiatry. This key innovation moves beyond static diagnostic categories by utilising real-time data to map and track the subtle and dynamic fluctuations within lived experience.
By integrating data from advanced biosensors, voice analysis, and various body metrics, we construct a fluid and personalised picture of an individual's mental states. This dynamic perspective reveals the continuous ebb and flow of attention, arousal, and emotional tone, providing a far more nuanced understanding than traditional, fixed labels. It allows for the identification of unique patterns and responses, enabling precise, state-based feedback and the co-creation of support maps tailored to an individual's specific needs and rhythms.
Biosensor Data: Wearable technologies and sensors capture physiological markers like heart rate variability, skin conductance, and brainwave patterns, offering objective insights into internal states.
Voice Analysis: Advanced algorithms analyse vocal tone, pitch, pace, and prosody to detect subtle shifts in emotional and cognitive states, providing real-time indicators of an individual's inner experience.
Body Metrics: Data from movement patterns, posture, and subtle physical expressions are integrated to understand the embodied aspects of mental states, reflecting energy levels and emotional expression.
Real-Time Ethnography and Somatic Tech
This card explores how cutting-edge wearable technology, combined with a deep attunement to embodied signals, allows for a nuanced, real-time understanding of an individual's mental and emotional landscape. This dynamic approach moves beyond static diagnostic labels to reveal fluid, lived patterns of experience.
Wearable Technology
Devices like the Muse headband and Apple Watch provide continuous streams of physiological data that can be correlated with subjective experience, offering a window into the body's moment-to-moment responses:
- ❤️🩹 Heart rate variability (HRV) serves as a crucial index of autonomic nervous system regulation, reflecting an individual's capacity to adapt to stress and maintain physiological balance. Lower HRV often correlates with states of stress or anxiety, while higher HRV indicates greater resilience.
- ⚡ Electrodermal activity (EDA), or skin conductance, directly reflects sympathetic nervous system arousal, indicating states of emotional intensity, stress, or engagement. Changes in EDA can signal subtle shifts in arousal that may not be consciously perceived.
- 🧠 Electroencephalogram (EEG) patterns, particularly those captured by portable devices like Muse, provide insights into brainwave activity associated with different states of attention, focus, and relaxation, aiding in understanding cognitive and emotional states.
- 🚶 Movement and activity levels, tracked throughout daily life, offer insights into behavioural patterns, energy levels, and potential correlations with mood states or physical manifestations of internal experiences.
Embodied Metrics
Beyond electronic sensors, Spiral State Psychiatry also attends to embodied signals—the observable manifestations of internal states—that provide rich qualitative data reflecting mental states:
- 😮💨 Breath patterns and respiratory variability offer immediate insights into emotional regulation. Shallow, rapid breathing might indicate anxiety, while deep, slow breaths are often linked to calm and grounded states.
- 🗣️ Voice tone, pace, and prosodic features convey a wealth of emotional information. Changes in pitch, volume, rhythm, and clarity can indicate shifts in mood, energy, or cognitive processing.
- ✋ Gestural patterns and postural shifts are non-verbal cues that express internal states. Subtle hand movements, body language, or changes in how one holds oneself can reveal underlying tension, comfort, or emotional expression.
- 😀 Facial expressions and micro-expressions provide direct, often unconscious, indicators of emotion. Observing these fleeting expressions can offer critical insights into an individual's immediate emotional experience.
By integrating data from both wearable technology and careful observation of embodied metrics, Spiral State Psychiatry constructs a comprehensive, multi-dimensional map of an individual's lived experience, enabling more personalised and responsive support.
State-Based Feedback
From Static Traits to Dynamic Insights for Responsive Care
Traditional Trait Model
The traditional psychiatric diagnostic model primarily focuses on enduring characteristics and stable traits, assuming that individuals' mental health conditions are fixed and consistent across various contexts. This approach often leads to categorical labels that can overlook the dynamic interplay of internal and external factors influencing a person's well-being.
It tends to classify individuals into rigid diagnostic categories based on symptom clusters that are perceived as immutable. This can sometimes result in a static understanding of a person, potentially limiting the scope of intervention and support to a one-size-fits-all approach rather than acknowledging individual variability and change over time.
Dynamic State Model
In contrast, a dynamic state model tracks fluctuating patterns and acknowledges that mental states are fluid and vary significantly across situations, time, and internal experiences. This perspective recognises that a person's well-being is not a fixed attribute but rather an emergent property of their interaction with their environment and internal processes.
This model moves beyond static labels to explore the continuous ebb and flow of emotional, cognitive, and physiological states. It seeks to understand the "how" and "when" of distress, recognising that symptoms may manifest differently or with varying intensity depending on specific triggers, contexts, and internal resources. This provides a more nuanced and ecologically valid understanding of lived experience.
Real-Time Feedback
Real-time feedback mechanisms provide immediate information about an individual's current state and its trajectory. Unlike periodic, retrospective assessments, this approach offers continuous, moment-by-moment insights into physiological markers, emotional shifts, and behavioural patterns as they unfold.
This continuous stream of data, potentially gathered through somatic technologies or self-reporting, allows for a precise understanding of when and how specific states emerge, how long they last, and what might influence their shifts. This immediacy enables both the individual and their support network to gain deeper awareness and respond proactively to emerging challenges or opportunities for change, fostering greater self-regulation and agency.
Adaptive Intervention
The core benefit of state-based feedback is the ability to offer support that is precisely tailored to present-moment needs, rather than being dictated by a broad diagnostic category. This shifts the focus from treating a static condition to supporting dynamic patterns of flourishing.
Adaptive interventions are highly personalised, adjusting in response to an individual's immediate state and its trajectory. For example, if real-time data indicates increasing physiological arousal, an intervention might be triggered to suggest a co-regulation exercise. This responsive approach allows for targeted, timely support that respects individual variability and promotes resilience by building skills directly relevant to a person's current experience, moving beyond rigid, generalised protocols.
Co-Constructed Support Maps
Co-constructed support maps: personal rhythm diaries, co-regulation protocols
Rather than relying on standardised treatment protocols dictated by a fixed diagnosis, Spiral State Psychiatry champions the collaborative creation of deeply personalised support strategies. These maps are built upon an individual's unique and fluctuating patterns, recognising that well-being is dynamic and context-dependent.
These maps are not static documents but living guides that evolve with the individual's experience. They integrate various tools and practices, with particular emphasis on:
Personal Rhythm Diaries
These are individualised tools for self-observation, allowing individuals to systematically track their internal states, energy fluctuations, sleep patterns, mood shifts, and environmental influences over time. By documenting these "rhythms," patterns emerge, helping to identify triggers, resources, and early warning signs.
- Promotes self-awareness and embodied understanding.
- Provides actionable data for personalised interventions.
- Shifts focus from pathology to dynamic states of being.
Co-Regulation Protocols
Co-regulation protocols are mutually agreed-upon strategies developed with a trusted support network (e.g., family, friends, therapists) to help manage and navigate challenging emotional or physiological states. They establish clear guidelines for how support can be offered and received, fostering healthy interdependence and reducing isolation.
- Builds resilient and responsive support systems.
- Empowers individuals and their network in crisis prevention.
- Moves beyond professional-centric care to shared responsibility.
Through this co-construction process, individuals become active participants in their healing journey, transforming what might traditionally be seen as symptoms into meaningful information about their unique internal landscape. This approach fosters agency, resilience, and a deeper connection to one's own lived experience.
Personal Rhythm Diaries
Personal rhythm diaries track patterns across different timescales, identifying both challenges and opportunities within natural fluctuations. This approach honours the wisdom of the body's rhythms rather than imposing external standards of consistency. By systematically observing and documenting an individual's unique biological and emotional rhythms, these diaries serve as a foundational tool for understanding one's internal landscape.
Unlike traditional diagnostic models that seek to categorise and pathologise deviations from perceived norms, rhythm diaries encourage a deeper attunement to inherent fluctuations. They reveal how energy levels, mood states, cognitive clarity, and social engagement shift throughout the day, week, month, and even across seasons. This detailed, lived data then informs the development of personalised "supportive strategies" that align with an individual's natural ebb and flow, optimising well-being by working *with* their rhythms, not against them.
The process of keeping a rhythm diary fosters a greater sense of self-awareness and agency. It empowers individuals to become active participants in their own care, recognising early signs of distress or moments of peak performance. This detailed self-observation is critical for co-constructing truly effective support maps, moving beyond a one-size-fits-all approach to mental health and embracing the dynamic, unique coherence of each person.
Co-Regulation Protocols
Co-regulation is the natural, reciprocal process by which two or more nervous systems attune to each other, fostering a sense of safety and balance. These protocols offer a structured framework for individuals and their support networks to intentionally engage in this process, moving beyond the myth of radical self-sufficiency towards relational well-being. They provide practical tools for navigating fluctuating states with shared support and understanding.
1
👁️ State Recognition
Developing awareness of current autonomic state through interoception and external feedback is the crucial first step. This involves tuning into subtle bodily cues, emotions, and thoughts, as well as observing how these states manifest in interactions with others. Recognising these patterns allows for proactive and responsive support.
2
💬 Communication System
Establishing clear and pre-agreed signals is vital for communicating needs to a support network during different states, especially when verbal communication might be challenging. This could involve simple phrases, non-verbal cues, or even designated safe words, ensuring that support can be offered effectively and without misunderstanding.
3
🤝 Tiered Response
Creating graduated levels of intervention matched to the intensity and nature of dysregulation ensures that support is appropriate and not overwhelming. This might range from a quiet, reassuring presence during mild discomfort to active co-regulation techniques or seeking professional assistance during more intense states of overwhelm or distress.
4
🔁 Regular Practice
Practising co-regulation strategies during regulated states is essential to build and strengthen the neural pathways associated with these responses. Consistent practice, even when not in crisis, integrates these protocols into daily life, making them more accessible and effective during moments of need and fostering greater resilience over time.
Co-regulation protocols deeply recognise that human nervous systems are inherently designed to regulate in relationship with others; we are social beings wired for connection. These structured approaches enable support networks to assist in state regulation without pathologising the natural human need for interpersonal support or framing it as a deficit. By embracing co-regulation, we move towards a model of care that values interdependence and relational healing.
Medicine Without Pathology
Reclaiming rhythm, ritual, and recursion as care
Spiral State Psychiatry envisions a form of medicine that supports health and flourishing 🌱 without requiring the identification of pathology as its starting point. This revolutionary approach moves beyond a deficit-based model, focusing instead on innate human capacities for self-organisation and growth. By reclaiming traditional healing practices centred on rhythm, ritual, and recursion, it integrates deep ancestral wisdom with contemporary scientific understanding of human experience and relational well-being.
Reclaiming rhythm 🎶 involves attuning to natural biological cycles and interpersonal synchronicity, recognising that dysregulation often stems from a disconnect with these inherent patterns. Ritual 📜 provides structured pathways for meaning-making, fostering community connection 🤝 and offering predictable frameworks for navigating life's complexities and transitions. Finally, recursion 🔄 emphasises the cyclical, iterative nature of healing and development, allowing for revisiting patterns with new insights and integrating past experiences into an evolving sense of self. This holistic framework aims to cultivate resilience and well-being ✨ by honouring the complex, dynamic nature of human existence, rather than segmenting it into disorders.
Reclaiming Rhythm
Reclaiming rhythm is fundamental to well-being in the Spiral State framework. It involves recognising and harmonising with the natural oscillatory patterns that govern our internal states and our interactions with the world. This approach emphasises practices that re-sync biological and psychological processes with natural, healing cadences.
Entrainment Practices
Entrainment refers to the synchronisation of biological rhythms with external rhythms. These rhythmic activities are powerful tools that help regulate the nervous system and foster a sense of internal balance through predictable and repetitive patterns. Engaging in these practices can enhance mental clarity, emotional stability, and physical well-being, promoting a coherent internal state.
- 🥁 Drumming circles and collective musical participation
- 💃 Improvised and structured dance and mindful movement sequences
- 🗣️ Chanting, vocal toning, and guided breathwork practices
- 🚶 Mindful walking, jogging, and rhythmic exercise in nature
- 🧶 Repetitive crafting (e.g., knitting, weaving) and meditative hand movements
- 🤝 Practising synchronised group activities and communal rituals
Temporal Medicine
Temporal medicine leverages the understanding of intrinsic biological and environmental temporal patterns to inform interventions. It involves working with, rather than against, natural temporal patterns and cycles. This approach acknowledges that timing and periodicity are crucial factors in health, influencing everything from mood regulation to cognitive function.
- 🛌 Chronotherapy tailored for sleep-wake cycles and mood regulation
- 🍂 Seasonal adjustment of activities, diet, and expectations
- ⏱️ Ultradian rhythm-based work/rest cycles for optimal productivity and recovery
- 🌸 Menstrual cycle awareness practices for holistic health and energy management
- ☀️ Daily routines aligned with circadian rhythms for improved sleep and digestion
- 💡 Utilising natural light exposure to reinforce internal biological clocks
By intentionally engaging with rhythmic and temporal practices, individuals can restore a sense of flow and coherence in their lives, moving beyond static diagnoses to embrace a dynamic process of healing and growth. This re-engagement with natural rhythms helps to build resilience and cultivate a more responsive and adaptable nervous system.
Ritual as Care
Ritual practices provide structured containers for experience that can support regulation, meaning-making, and transformation. In the framework of Spiral State Psychiatry, these practices are seen not as mere traditions, but as essential tools for fostering mental and emotional well-being by engaging with the inherent rhythms of life and promoting adaptive state shifts. This approach recognised the profound therapeutic value of:
Transition Rituals
Structured practices that support navigation of life changes and developmental shifts, providing containment during periods of uncertainty and reorganisation. These can include rites of passage for adolescence or adulthood, grief ceremonies for loss, or even personal rituals for marking career transitions or significant personal growth. They help individuals integrate new experiences and identities, fostering psychological resilience and a sense of continuity during periods of discontinuity.
Community Ceremonies
Collective rituals that strengthen social bonds, create shared meaning, and provide validation of individual experiences within a larger context. By participating in shared practices, individuals feel a sense of belonging and mutual support, counteracting feelings of isolation and alienation. These ceremonies can range from seasonal celebrations to gatherings that acknowledge shared struggles or triumphs, reinforcing collective identity and fostering a sense of interconnectedness.
Daily Practices
Regular rituals that create rhythm and predictability in daily life, supporting nervous system regulation and providing anchors during challenging periods. Simple daily rituals, such as a morning routine, mindful eating, or a gratitude practice before bed, can build a sense of stability and self-awareness. They help individuals consciously engage with their internal states and external environment, promoting a feeling of agency and control amidst life's fluctuations.
Symbolic Actions
Meaningful gestures and practices that engage the non-verbal, embodied dimensions of experience, allowing for expression and transformation beyond the limits of language. These actions can be powerful tools for processing emotions, releasing tension, or enacting desired changes in one's life. By engaging with symbols and metaphors, individuals can access deeper layers of meaning and facilitate healing that might be inaccessible through purely cognitive or linguistic approaches.
By integrating these ritual practices, Spiral State Psychiatry offers a holistic and culturally sensitive approach to care, moving beyond pathology-focused models to embrace the innate human capacity for self-organisation and meaning-making within complex lived experiences. These rituals provide frameworks for navigating the dynamic interplay of states, fostering coherence and well-being.
Recursion as Healing
Healing is not always a linear path; often, it involves revisiting familiar territories with new perspectives and deepened capacities. This card explores how recursive processes, characterised by cycles of return and integration, facilitate profound and lasting transformation in the context of mental health and well-being.
1
1
Noticing Patterns
Developing a keen awareness of recurring themes, emotional responses, and behavioural patterns is the foundational step. This involves observing not just external events but also internal states, thoughts, and bodily sensations that tend to repeat in similar situations, providing crucial data for understanding one's own unique system.
2
2
Reflective Capacity
Building the ability to observe one's own process from a compassionate and non-judgmental stance is essential. This meta-awareness allows individuals to step back from immediate reactions, gaining perspective on their experiences without being overwhelmed or defined by them, and fostering a sense of agency over their inner world.
3
3
Choice Points
Identifying moments where new responses become possible within these recurring patterns is key to transformative healing. These "choice points" are opportunities to intentionally interrupt old cycles, experiment with novel behaviours, or engage with situations in a way that aligns with emerging awareness, breaking free from autopilot reactions.
4
4
Integration
Incorporating new patterns into embodied experience means more than just intellectual understanding; it's about deeply embedding these changes into one's nervous system and daily actions. Through repeated practice and lived experience, new ways of being become more automatic and accessible, solidifying the shifts achieved through recursive engagement.
Recursive approaches to healing recognise that transformation often occurs through spirals of returning to similar situations with new awareness and capacities. Rather than seeing recurrence as failure or a setback, this approach values the deepening that happens through revisiting core themes with expanded consciousness. Each pass through a familiar challenge, armed with increased insight and skills, allows for a more nuanced understanding and a more integrated resolution. This continuous, spiralling process builds resilience and fosters a profound sense of growth, moving beyond linear notions of progress.
This perspective fundamentally shifts how we approach mental well-being, emphasising iterative learning and the refinement of internal resources. It encourages patience and self-compassion, acknowledging that complex human experiences unfold in dynamic, non-linear ways. By embracing recursion, individuals can transform challenges into opportunities for deeper healing and a more coherent sense of self.
Nonlinear Timelines 🔄
Embracing the inherent unpredictability of human experience, Spiral State Psychiatry proposes nonlinear timelines for healing and growth, moving beyond rigid, step-by-step recovery narratives.
It challenges the linear progression models that dominate conventional approaches to mental health, recognising that healing and growth often follow nonlinear trajectories that include apparent setbacks, plateaus, and unexpected leaps forward 🎢.
This approach acknowledges that perceived "setbacks" or periods of stagnation are not failures but integral parts of the spiralling process of transformation. Just as nature cycles through seasons 🌳, human well-being involves phases of contraction and expansion, rest and activity, all contributing to holistic development.
By de-pathologising these natural fluctuations, we foster an environment where individuals can engage authentically with their internal rhythms. This perspective empowers individuals to trust their unique journey ✨, free from the pressure of conforming to a predefined, linear path of improvement, recognising that profound and sustainable growth often emerges from periods of deep introspection or apparent regression.
Beyond Progress Narratives
Embracing the inherent nonlinearity of human development and well-being
In the landscape of mental health, the way we conceptualise progress profoundly shapes the experience of healing. Traditional models often push for a relentless forward march, where any deviation from a continuous upward trajectory is deemed a failure. Spiral State Psychiatry offers a radical reimagining, embracing the inherent nonlinearity of human development and well-being.
The Conventional Linear Model: A Straitjacket for Complexity
Traditional approaches often operate under the assumption of a straightforward progression from illness to health. Within this framework, any perceived setback, fluctuation, or return to challenging states is frequently labelled as a "failure," "relapse," or a sign of treatment ineffectiveness. This linear model imposes several limitations:
- 📈 Measures success by continuous improvement: It prioritises an uninterrupted upward trend in well-being, overlooking the natural ebb and flow of human experience.
- 📉 Views fluctuations as problematic: Normal variations in mood, energy, or coping capacity are often pathologised, leading to unnecessary interventions or self-blame.
- 🏃♀️ Creates pressure for constant progress: Individuals feel immense pressure to always be "getting better," fostering anxiety and shame when they inevitably encounter difficulties.
- 🔄 Pathologises cycles and rhythms: Natural human cycles—be then emotional, seasonal, or related to life stages—are often misconstrued as symptoms of disorder rather than inherent patterns of life. This can lead to an overemphasis on symptom eradication over understanding underlying patterns.
- 😔 Fosters a sense of inadequacy: When progress isn't linear, individuals can feel like they are failing or that something is inherently wrong with them, rather than recognising the natural complexities of growth.
The Spiral State Model: Embracing the Dance of Growth
A nonlinear approach, central to Spiral State Theory, recognises that healing and growth follow a spiral nature. This means revisiting challenging states is not a failure but a crucial opportunity for deeper integration, refinement, and a more profound understanding of self. This model shifts the paradigm:
- 💫 Values the wisdom gained through cycles: It sees each return to a previously encountered state not as a relapse, but as a chance to integrate lessons more deeply and develop new resources from a higher vantage point.
- 🧩 Recognises integration as distinct from elimination: The goal isn't necessarily to eliminate difficult feelings or experiences, but to integrate them into one's narrative and capacity, transforming their impact.
- 🧘♀️ Honours the necessary phases of contraction: Periods of withdrawal, introspection, or emotional difficulty are seen as vital, regenerative phases akin to winter in a natural cycle, essential for renewal and subsequent expansion.
- 💪 Measures success by increased capacity and resilience: Instead of just symptom reduction, progress is understood as an enhanced ability to navigate life's complexities, to recover more effectively from challenges, and to cultivate greater self-awareness.
- ❤️ Cultivates self-compassion: By normalising the nonlinear nature of growth, it frees individuals from the burden of constant "progress," encouraging acceptance and patience with their own unique journey.
By shifting from a linear "progress narrative" to a spiral understanding, Spiral State Psychiatry invites a more compassionate, realistic, and ultimately more effective approach to well-being, recognising that true healing often involves dancing with, rather than fleeing from, life's inherent rhythms.
Developmental Spirals
1
2
3
4
1
Expansion
Periods of growth, exploration, and new learning. This phase is characterised by an outward movement, taking in new information, experimenting with new behaviours, and pushing the boundaries of what is known. It's a time of optimism and open possibilities, fostering curiosity and engagement with the world.
2
Challenge
Encountering limitations and difficulties that reveal edges. As new territories are explored, inevitable obstacles and unexpected complexities arise. This phase tests existing coping mechanisms, highlights areas where current strategies are insufficient, and prompts a necessary period of self-reflection and adaptation.
3
Contraction
Withdrawal to process and integrate new experiences. After facing challenges, there is a natural pull inward. This period involves introspection, rest, and consolidation of new insights, allowing for the deep assimilation of lessons learned and the quiet recalibration of internal resources.
4
Emergence
Returning with new capacities and understanding. From the period of contraction, individuals re-engage with the world, not as they were before, but with enhanced resilience, novel skills, and a deeper sense of self. This phase marks a higher point on the spiral, ready for the next cycle of expansion.
Rather than seeing development as a straight line of continuous improvement, Spiral State Psychiatry recognises these recurring phases as essential to genuine growth. Each cycle revisits similar themes at deeper levels of integration and complexity, building upon previous experiences rather than simply repeating them. This nonlinear approach acknowledges that periods of struggle and withdrawal are not setbacks, but integral parts of a healthy, adaptive process.
Understanding these developmental spirals allows for a more compassionate and realistic view of mental well-being, fostering resilience and encouraging a nuanced appreciation for the rhythms of human experience. It shifts the focus from avoiding difficulties to learning how to navigate them effectively, transforming challenges into opportunities for profound personal evolution.
Field Resonance
Field resonance, not symptom suppression
Instead of targeting isolated symptoms for suppression or elimination, Spiral State Psychiatry works with the principle of field resonance—the capacity for nervous systems to attune and regulate through relationship with other coherent systems. This approach shifts the focus from individual pathology to the dynamic interplay between individuals and their relational, social, and environmental contexts. It acknowledges that human experience is deeply interconnected and that well-being emerges from harmonious interactions within these broader "fields."
This paradigm recognises that the human nervous system is inherently designed for co-regulation. When an individual's system is dysregulated or experiencing distress, it can resonate with the stability and coherence of another well-regulated system. This is not about one person "fixing" another, but rather about creating a relational field where mutual attunement and subtle energetic exchange facilitate natural re-patterning and healing. Therapists, peers, and even nurturing environments can serve as coherent systems that offer a stabilising influence, helping to guide the client's internal state towards greater equilibrium and adaptive functioning.
Interpersonal Neurobiology
Drawing deeply from the foundational work of Dr. Daniel Siegel and other pioneering researchers, Spiral State Psychiatry firmly recognises that the human nervous system is not an isolated entity. Instead, it develops, organises, and regulates itself dynamically in continuous interaction with other nervous systems. This profound understanding of relational dynamics moves beyond individual pathology, informing a holistic suite of approaches that:
- Value the regulatory power of attuned presence: Practitioners cultivate a deep, empathetic presence, offering a receptive and responsive relational field that helps clients feel seen, safe, and understood, thereby fostering intrinsic self-regulation.
- Recognise how providers' own state affects clients: Understanding the concept of "nervous system contagion" or "limbic resonance," Spiral State Psychiatry emphasises that the practitioner's internal state directly influences the client's capacity for regulation and openness to change.
- Utilise co-regulation as a primary intervention: Rather than solely relying on self-regulation, interventions prioritise the shared, reciprocal process of co-regulation. This involves conscious rhythmic interaction, mirroring, and emotional validation to gently guide the client's nervous system towards greater coherence.
- Train awareness of interpersonal resonance: Practitioners are trained to perceive subtle non-verbal cues and energetic shifts within the relational field, honing their sensitivity to the unspoken communication between nervous systems.
- Develop practices for maintaining regulated presence: Ongoing personal practices such as mindfulness, self-compassion, and consistent peer supervision are integrated into training, ensuring practitioners can maintain their own regulated presence even in challenging therapeutic encounters.
By consciously attending to the profound quality of the therapeutic relationship and the nuanced interplay of presence, practitioners within Spiral State Psychiatry can create expansive, supportive fields. These fields naturally foster regulation, integration, and a return to inherent flexibility and coherence, fundamentally shifting the focus away from explicit symptom reduction towards a more organic, relational healing process. This approach facilitates a natural emergence of well-being, acknowledging the interconnectedness of mind, body, and relationship.
Environmental Attunement
Spiral State Psychiatry recognises that our internal states are deeply interconnected with the environments we inhabit. This principle of environmental attunement emphasises the profound impact that physical, social, and natural surroundings have on our nervous systems and overall well-being. By consciously shaping these external fields, we can foster states of coherence and regulation, moving beyond symptom-focused interventions to embrace a holistic view of care.
Physical Spaces 🏡
Creating environments that support regulation through careful attention to sensory elements like light and sound, thoughtful spatial arrangement, the integration of natural elements, and rhythmic features that subtly entrain the nervous system toward greater coherence. This involves designing spaces that feel safe, calming, and conducive to a sense of grounded presence.
Social Fields 🤝
Cultivating group contexts characterised by safety, reciprocity, and attunement that allow for co-regulation and collective resource generation rather than contagion of dysregulation. This extends to therapeutic groups, family systems, and community networks, where healthy relational dynamics actively support individual and collective well-being.
Natural Resonance 🌳
Facilitating direct connection with natural rhythms and patterns that have regulated human nervous systems throughout evolutionary history, from circadian light exposure to seasonal shifts and direct contact with living systems. Engaging with the natural world provides powerful, inherent pathways for restoring balance and promoting a sense of belonging.
This approach moves beyond simply treating individual symptoms, recognising that a person's lived experience is always nested within a larger environmental context. Just as a plant thrives or withers based on its soil, light, and water, human beings are profoundly influenced by the "field" in which they are embedded.
Field resonance approaches understand that direct manipulation of symptoms often creates compensatory responses, while changing the field in which a person is embedded can allow for organic reorganisation toward greater coherence and well-being. This paradigm shift emphasises prevention, resilience, and the creation of conditions that naturally support healing and flourishing.
Ethical and Philosophical Foundations
Spiral State Psychiatry is deeply rooted in ethical commitments and philosophical perspectives that redefine how we understand and support mental health and human flourishing.
It champions the idea of ‘complexity without stigma’ 🧬, embracing the inherent multifaceted and dynamic nature of human experience. This paradigm moves beyond simplistic, static diagnoses, viewing challenges not as fixed pathologies but as emergent properties within complex, evolving systems.
A central tenet is ‘reciprocity in care’ ⚖️, fostering genuinely collaborative relationships. Individuals are recognised as active agents in their healing journeys, participating in mutual respect, shared decision-making, and the co-creation of supportive environments.
Ultimately, Spiral State Psychiatry aims to foster flourishing as ‘spiralled coherence’ – a dynamic process of ongoing growth and integration, rather than a rigid return to a predefined ‘normality.’ It celebrates neurodiversity and the plural mind, promoting a framework where unique lived experiences are valued as variations of human potential, not deviations.
Complexity Without Stigma
Embracing Complexity 🌿
Spiral State Psychiatry fundamentally challenges conventional views by recognising the inherent complexity of human experience, refusing to reduce it to simplistic diagnostic categories or pathologising natural differences. This paradigm shift encourages a deeper understanding of individuals, acknowledging that mental well-being is a dynamic, multi-dimensional interplay of internal states and external contexts. This approach:
- Values the richness of diverse mental states, understanding that each state, whether joy, grief, or confusion, offers unique perspectives and information about an individual's journey. Instead of labelling these states as inherently "good" or "bad," it seeks to understand their adaptive function within a person's life.
- Acknowledges the multifaceted nature of distress, recognising that suffering often arises from a complex interplay of biological, psychological, social, and environmental factors, rather than a single root cause. This holistic view moves beyond symptomatic relief to address underlying systemic issues.
- Recognises the contextual nature of all experience, asserting that a person's thoughts, feelings, and behaviours are deeply intertwined with their environment, relationships, and life history. What might appear as a "dysfunction" in one context could be a protective response in another.
- Appreciates the wisdom in seemingly difficult states, viewing intense or challenging experiences not as flaws to be eradicated, but as signals carrying valuable information about unmet needs or adaptive strategies. These states can be pathways to growth and deeper self-understanding.
By fostering an environment that celebrates the nuanced tapestry of human existence, Spiral State Psychiatry moves away from rigid classifications, instead focusing on the individual's unique patterns and pathways. It aims to see the whole person, not just a collection of symptoms, thus promoting a more compassionate and comprehensive form of care.
Challenging Stigma 🤝
By moving beyond the binary of normal versus pathological, this approach actively works to reduce the pervasive stigma often associated with mental health challenges. It redefines what it means to experience distress, shifting the narrative from individual failing to universal human experience. This is achieved through:
- Normalising the full spectrum of human experience, creating a space where intense emotions, unconventional thought patterns, or unique sensory experiences are understood as variations of human consciousness rather than deviations from an arbitrary norm. This fosters acceptance and reduces isolation.
- Recognising universal vulnerability to suffering, acknowledging that all individuals, at various points in their lives, will encounter forms of distress, loss, or challenge. This shared humanity builds empathy and dismantles the "us vs. them" mentality that fuels stigma.
- Honouring the adaptive nature of many "symptoms," understanding that behaviours often labelled as symptomatic can be highly functional survival strategies developed in response to difficult circumstances or trauma. This perspective reframes pathology as a potential source of strength or resilience.
- Focusing on capacity and resilience alongside challenge, ensuring that conversations about mental health are not solely problem-focused but also highlight an individual's inherent strengths, coping mechanisms, and potential for growth. This empowers individuals and fosters hope.
This commitment to challenging stigma is foundational to building a more inclusive and supportive society, where individuals feel safe to seek help and engage in their healing journey without fear of judgment or marginalisation. Spiral State Psychiatry champions a human-centred approach that prioritises dignity and respect above all else.
Reciprocity in Care
Reciprocity in care moves beyond a one-way transfer of knowledge or healing, fostering a dynamic where all participants are active agents in a process of mutual growth and transformation. This approach emphasises that true healing emerges from a collaborative space where client and practitioner evolve together, continually shaping each other's understanding and well-being.
Mutual Transformation
Recognising that therapeutic relationships inherently change both parties, we challenge the conventional notion of the unchanging expert and the passively changing client. This dynamic process acknowledges the profound impact clients have on practitioners, fostering an environment where both can learn and grow from their shared journey.
Bidirectional Learning
Valuing the profound wisdom and nuanced knowledge that emerges from lived experience alongside professional training and scientific research. This means actively listening to and integrating the client's unique insights, recognising them as essential contributors to the therapeutic process, and not just recipients of intervention.
Shared Authority
Distributing decision-making power and recognising multiple forms of expertise within the therapeutic process. This involves fostering a collaborative dialogue where goals, methods, and outcomes are co-created, empowering clients to be active participants in their own care plans and acknowledging their inherent competence.
Co-Becoming
Understanding that all participants in care relationships are continually evolving through their interactions with each other. This perspective views care not as a fixed state, but as an ongoing, fluid process where individuals are in a constant state of emergence, transforming and adapting in response to their relational context.
Relational Attunement
Emphasising the deep connection and responsiveness between individuals in the care setting. This involves cultivating empathy, presence, and responsiveness, allowing for a flexible and sensitive engagement that shifts with the evolving needs and expressions of both client and practitioner.
Integration of Perspectives
Promoting a holistic view that integrates diverse perspectives, including biological, psychological, social, and spiritual dimensions. This collaborative integration ensures that care is comprehensive and person-centred, moving beyond reductionist views to embrace the full spectrum of human experience.
Ethical Foundations
Spiral State Psychiatry re-evaluates and expands upon the core ethical principles that underpin clinical care, offering a framework that prioritises reciprocity, complexity, and profound self-determination over traditional expert authority and normalisation.
In Spiral State Psychiatry, autonomy extends beyond merely consenting to a treatment plan devised by an expert. It involves a profound co-creative process where individuals, alongside practitioners, actively shape the therapeutic approach. This shared exploration acknowledges the person's unique lived experience, wisdom, and preferences as central to defining their path towards well-being, moving from a passive reception of care to active partnership.
Traditional beneficence often focuses on symptom reduction as defined by diagnostic categories. However, within the Spiral State framework, beneficence is reimagined as supporting an individual's unique journey toward flourishing. This means empowering individuals to define what "well-being" means to them, aligning care with their personal values, goals, and aspirations, rather than imposing external norms of mental health.
Non-maleficence, traditionally centred on avoiding direct physical or psychological harm from interventions, is broadened to actively prevent the more subtle yet profound harms of pathologisation and power imbalance. This includes protecting individuals from the negative impacts of labelling, stigma, and the disempowerment that can arise from rigid hierarchical relationships in care settings. Emphasis is placed on creating environments of safety and mutual respect.
Finally, the principle of justice moves beyond ensuring equal access to standardised treatments. Spiral State Psychiatry advocates for equitable access to a diverse array of resources that support self-determined flourishing. This acknowledges that individuals have unique needs and that true justice involves providing flexible, culturally sensitive, and personalised pathways to well-being, ensuring that all people have the opportunity to thrive on their own terms.
Flourishing as Spiralled Coherence
Flourishing as spiralled coherence, not forced normality.
Rather than defining health as conformity to statistical norms or absence of symptoms, Spiral State Psychiatry understands flourishing as the achievement of coherence that honours complexity and supports meaningful engagement with life. This perspective moves beyond a static, diagnostic view of well-being, embracing a dynamic and individualised process.
Spiralled coherence implies a state where an individual's internal rhythms, cognitive patterns, emotional experiences, and interpersonal connections are in harmonious, yet constantly evolving, alignment. It's not about eradicating difficult experiences, but rather integrating them into a richer, more comprehensive sense of self and purpose. This allows for growth through challenges, recognising that true vitality often emerges from navigating complexity, rather than suppressing it.
This approach emphasises the unique pathways each person takes in their journey toward well-being, valuing the diversity of human experience and acknowledging that "health" is a fluid, co-created state. Flourishing, in this context, is the capacity to adapt, integrate, and find meaning within one's lived experience, fostering a deep and authentic connection to oneself and the world.
Beyond Normality
Limitations of Normative Models
Traditional approaches often define health as statistical normality or conformity to social expectations. This framework, while seemingly straightforward, has significant drawbacks and limitations:
- 🌍Pathologises natural human diversity: By setting narrow definitions of "normal" behaviour, thought, and emotion, it tends to label natural variations in human experience as disorders. This includes neurodivergence, intense emotional responses, or unconventional ways of processing information, leading to unnecessary diagnoses and stigmatisation.
- ⛓️Reinforces harmful social norms: These models often implicitly uphold prevailing societal expectations, pushing individuals to conform to what is deemed acceptable by the majority, rather than celebrating individuality. This can perpetuate biases and marginalise those who do not fit in.
- 🌐Ignores cultural and contextual factors: Mental health is deeply intertwined with cultural background, socio-economic status, personal history, and environmental influences. A purely normative lens often overlooks these critical determinants, leading to misinterpretations of behaviour and ineffective, culturally insensitive interventions.
- ✨Devalues unique gifts and perspectives: A focus on deficits or deviations from the norm can overshadow and suppress the inherent strengths, creative capacities, and unique contributions that individuals bring. It can lead to a sense of brokenness instead of recognising inherent value.
- 🌱Fosters a deficit-based mindset: This approach inherently seeks out what is "wrong" or "missing" in an individual, rather than exploring their full potential and resources for growth and adaptation. It prioritises symptom reduction over holistic flourishing.
Coherence as Alternative
Spiral State Psychiatry proposes coherence rather than normality as a guiding principle for well-being. Coherence offers a more dynamic, inclusive, and empowering understanding of health, focusing on the intricate dance of internal and external processes:
- 🧩Integration of diverse aspects of experience: Coherence involves the harmonious bringing together of thoughts, feelings, bodily sensations, memories, and interpersonal relationships. It's about fostering internal alignment, allowing different parts of oneself to work together constructively rather than being in conflict or fragmented.
- 🧭Alignment with personal values and meaning: True well-being emerges when an individual's actions, thoughts, and feelings are congruent with their deepest values, sense of purpose, and what they find meaningful in life. Coherence supports living authentically and purposefully.
- 🌊Flexible adaptation to changing contexts: Unlike rigid normality, coherence emphasises the capacity to navigate life's inherent complexities and constant change with resilience and grace. It's about maintaining a stable yet adaptable sense of self while responding effectively to novel or challenging situations.
- 🔋Sustainable patterns that support vitality: Coherent states are characterised by internal harmony and balance, leading to increased energy, emotional regulation, and overall well-being. These patterns promote long-term vitality and prevent burnout, enabling individuals to engage with life from a place of strength.
- ☯️Embraces complexity and paradox: Coherence recognises that life often involves paradox and contradiction, and instead of seeking to eliminate these, it allows for their integration. It acknowledges that healing and growth are often nonlinear processes.
Spiralled Coherence
1
1
🧬 Integration
Connecting diverse aspects of experience—thoughts, emotions, bodily sensations, and spiritual insights—into a unified and evolving whole. This involves weaving together past experiences with present awareness to inform future possibilities, fostering an inner harmony.
2
2
🌊 Flow
Moving fluidly and adaptably between different states of being as appropriate to the context and demands of life. This responsiveness allows for effortless navigation through challenges and opportunities, maintaining engagement without rigidity or stagnation.
3
3
⚖️ Harmony
Achieving a dynamic balance that honours all dimensions of being—physical, emotional, mental, and relational. It's not about static perfection, but a continuous adjustment and resonance within oneself and with the external world.
4
4
🎭 Authenticity
Embracing and expressing one's true self, values, and experiences without compromise. This involves shedding societal expectations and internalised norms to live in alignment with one's genuine inner landscape, fostering deep self-acceptance.
5
5
✨ Meaning
Engaging with life in ways that feel profoundly purposeful, valuable, and authentic. This involves discovering and cultivating a sense of personal significance that transcends mere existence, connecting to a larger narrative or vision.
6
6
🌱 Resilience
The inherent capacity to adapt and bounce back from adversity, stress, and trauma. Spiralled coherence fosters a robust ability to learn from challenging experiences, transforming them into opportunities for growth and deeper self-understanding.
7
7
🚀 Growth
Embracing a continuous process of evolution and self-actualisation. This involves moving beyond fixed limitations, exploring new potentials, and expanding one's capacity for experience, learning, and connection throughout life's journey.
Spiralled coherence recognises that flourishing is not a static endpoint but a dynamic process of continuous integration at increasingly complex levels. Unlike traditional models that might seek to normalise or fix perceived deviations, this framework celebrates the inherent diversity of human experience. It embraces the full spectrum of human expression—including difficult emotions, altered states of consciousness, and unique neurological perspectives—as integral components of a rich and coherent life.
This vision of health supports the ongoing development of coherence that allows for deeply meaningful engagement with oneself, with others, and with the surrounding world. It encourages individuals to navigate their internal landscapes with curiosity and compassion, fostering a sense of agency and belonging. By focusing on dynamic processes rather than rigid outcomes, Spiralled Coherence provides a flexible and empowering paradigm for mental well-being and personal evolution, enabling individuals to cultivate a life that is both coherent and authentically their own.
Clinical Resources & Further Reading
To delve deeper into the concepts and applications of Spiral State Psychiatry and related emergent models, explore these comprehensive resources:
1
Foundational Principles
Explore the core tenets, frameworks, and practical applications of Spiral State Psychiatry.
2
Specialised Applications
Discover how the Spiral approach is applied to specific clinical challenges and therapeutic modalities.
3
Neurobiological & Contemporary Perspectives
Gain insights into the neuroscientific underpinnings and modern psychiatric discourse.
These resources offer a comprehensive view of the ongoing evolution in psychiatric thought, moving towards models that embrace complexity, coherence, and the dynamic nature of human well-being.